Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 24

Thread: Has Affirmative Action Outlived Its Usefulness in the Workplace?

  1. #1
    Citizen Cope
    Zere's Avatar

    Country
    This is Zere's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Posts
    3,281

    Has Affirmative Action Outlived Its Usefulness in the Workplace?

    Discuss.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Chess Champion.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Fantasy Football Champion.

    FREE MONEY!!!

    you sign up, get 10 free cents to bet on all kinds of sports, get to 20 dollars you can cash out real money. If you lose the 10 cents they give you 10 more cents for free.

    http://www.centsports.com/?opcode=182035

  2. #2
    The New Flesh
    henry's Avatar

    Country
    This is henry's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    yuma
    Posts
    6,082

    we should discuss this on your blog

  3. #3
    Oderus
    Odin's Avatar

    Country
    This is Odin's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Hockeytown
    Posts
    10,669

    was it ever useful to not hire the most qualified person to fill a quota?

    War is Peace
    Freedom is Slavery
    Ignorance is Strength

    One of the ultimate things a human can learn is kindness for their fellow humans.
    Id like to teach those things to my children.
    -Evan Tanner

  4. #4
    Affirmative Action never had a use in the workplace. As Odin said, it is at odds with good hiring practices.

    Its use politically and socially was to bring minorities into the workplace and thus elevate them socially. That has obviously failed as well, considering blacks in particular have been regressing in almost every social standard.

    Read:

    Affirmative Action Around the World: An Empirical Study


    and



    both by Thomas Sowell.

    I believe I posted an audiobook to the second one in the stash

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  5. #5
    Citizen Cope
    Zere's Avatar

    Country
    This is Zere's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Posts
    3,281

    On Monday I have to debate for affirmative action in one of my classes. So over the next few days I'm going to argue for affirmative action. I'd appreciate it if you guys do your best to tear the arguments apart, so I will be prepared for the debate. Thanks in advance.

    THIS MAY GET HEATED.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Chess Champion.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Fantasy Football Champion.

    FREE MONEY!!!

    you sign up, get 10 free cents to bet on all kinds of sports, get to 20 dollars you can cash out real money. If you lose the 10 cents they give you 10 more cents for free.

    http://www.centsports.com/?opcode=182035

  6. #6
    Oderus
    Odin's Avatar

    Country
    This is Odin's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Hockeytown
    Posts
    10,669

    would you rather have the most qualified cops and firemen getting jobs, or the color corrected ones? who would you feel safer with?

    War is Peace
    Freedom is Slavery
    Ignorance is Strength

    One of the ultimate things a human can learn is kindness for their fellow humans.
    Id like to teach those things to my children.
    -Evan Tanner

  7. #7
    Oderus
    Odin's Avatar

    Country
    This is Odin's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Hockeytown
    Posts
    10,669

    Quote Originally Posted by Pepper Corn View Post
    and who gives a shit. bitching about a fact of life won't change nothing.
    it just might get black panthers knocking on yer door.
    spoken like someone whos never missed out on a job they were the most qualified for because someone needed to fill a quota that you didnt fit.

    War is Peace
    Freedom is Slavery
    Ignorance is Strength

    One of the ultimate things a human can learn is kindness for their fellow humans.
    Id like to teach those things to my children.
    -Evan Tanner

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by Zere View Post
    On Monday I have to debate for affirmative action in one of my classes. So over the next few days I'm going to argue for affirmative action. I'd appreciate it if you guys do your best to tear the arguments apart, so I will be prepared for the debate. Thanks in advance.

    THIS MAY GET HEATED.
    Post your arguments in the War Room and I will tear them apart for you.

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  9. #9
    Will this be a real debate with a structure and time limits or the more typical college debate consisting of standing up in front of class and trying to talk over the other?

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  10. #10
    Oderus
    Odin's Avatar

    Country
    This is Odin's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Hockeytown
    Posts
    10,669

    Quote Originally Posted by Pepper Corn View Post
    nah, i been there.
    a few times in fact.
    my sweet husband/provider is there RIGHT FUCKING now.
    like this very moment at his job this is going down.

    but the complaining - it's like pissing against the wind - you get what i'm saying?
    not complaining. i live in detroit. im well used to seeing under-qualified people get jobs and scholarships based on the color of their skin. well used to seeing them piss said opportunities away as well. but they boy needs discussion for debate so i can oblige him.

    War is Peace
    Freedom is Slavery
    Ignorance is Strength

    One of the ultimate things a human can learn is kindness for their fellow humans.
    Id like to teach those things to my children.
    -Evan Tanner

  11. #11
    Quote Originally Posted by Pepper Corn View Post
    but the complaining - it's like pissing against the wind - you get what i'm saying?
    LOL so being upset about injustice is useless? I don't mean to get all self-righteous, but what would Martin Luther King, Jr. say?

    Quote Originally Posted by Pepper Corn View Post
    the thing is - i have lived a few places - and i have SEEN minorities get "oppressed" time and time again.
    really it's just shitty that we live in a society where people fucking judge you on skin color. it is a double edge sword though. i think it's important to remember that.
    Minorities are oppressed all the time...it is an unfortunate fact of life...but the fact of the matter is Affirmative Action does not serve anyone except for a select few people's interests in the long run.

    Places of employment are deprived of the most capable workers available, qualified members of the "majority" is lose jobs, and people from "minority" groups are allowed to continue in an unsuccessful and unadapted culture.
    Last edited by Reaper Man; 09-24-2009 at 10:36 PM.

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  12. #12
    International Affirmative Action by Thomas Sowell

    As the Supreme Court of the United States wrestles with the issue of affirmative action as it exists in college admissions at the University of Michigan, the justices are taking on an issue that has been wrestled with in many contexts by courts in India for far longer than group preferences and quotas have existed in the United States.

    India is not the only other country with affirmative action, though it has had such programs longer than any other, going all the way back to the days when India was part of the British Empire.

    Affirmative action has existed in countries on every inhabited continent -- not only in democratic countries like India and Britain, but in totalitarian countries like the Soviet Union and China, as well as in Nigeria, Malaysia, New Zealand, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka, among others.

    How have these programs worked out in other countries? There are certain common patterns -- and certain unique differences.

    Perhaps the most widespread similarity among programs in these very different countries has been that group preferences and quotas are almost always discussed -- by critics and advocates alike -- in terms of their rationales, rather than their actual results. Some countries have not even bothered to collect data on outcomes.

    The most common outcome is that the benefits of affirmative action programs go to only a small minority within the groups that are supposed to benefit from them. This is almost invariably the already most prosperous segment of these groups.

    In India, for example, it has long been known that many university places reserved for Dalits -- formerly known as "untouchables" -- remain unfilled. Where the various benefits offered are actually used, they are used disproportionately by particular subgroups who have the money, education, and other advantages that enable them to make use of preferential access to higher education, higher level jobs, and the like.

    In India this problem has been so widely recognized that there have in recent years been demands for a "quota within quota," so that the more fortunate subgroups do not continue to take the lion's share of the benefits from affirmative action. A similar problem exists within the United States, but has not been nearly so widely recognized.

    Another common pattern is that group preferences have been initiated as temporary measures. But even where these programs have begun with a specified cutoff date -- as in Pakistan, Malaysia, and India -- these programs have continued on for decades past those cutoff dates by subsequent extensions, with no end yet in sight. Often these programs have not only persisted but expanded, covering more sectors or more groups, or both.

    Perhaps the most ominous common pattern has been a backlash by others who resent the special preferences given to particular groups. In India, violence against Dalits has escalated in the wake of preferences on their behalf -- preferences which, ironically, relatively few Dalits are able to take advantage of.

    In Sri Lanka, where the groups live concentrated in different regions, the escalation of violence has gone all the way to civil war. This small nation has suffered more deaths from this internal strife than the United States suffered during all the long years of the Vietnam war.

    Where have large-scale group preferences been successful, at least in the sense that they have benefited large numbers of people in one group without either ruining another group or degenerating into violent internal strife? Malaysia may be the prime example, but it has had unique features that may not enable it to be a model for other countries.

    First, group preferences in Malaysia began in 1970 and were carried out while the country experienced unusually rapid economic growth and transformation from a predominantly agricultural nation to a modern commercial and industrial society. A rising tide raised all boats.

    Another key factor is that it is a federal crime in Malaysia to promote intergroup strife. There can be no careers like those of Jesse Jackson or Al Sharpton in Malaysia. For countries where free speech is basic, Malaysia is not a model that can be imitated.
    "Affirmative Action" and College Graduation Rates by Thomas Sowell

    When racial preferences were ended in California, there was much hysteria in the media, with dire predictions that blacks would be kept out of higher education. Just recently, with much less publicity, the fact has come out that there are now more black students in the University of California system than there were when racial preferences and quotas were in effect. The same is true in the University of Texas system.

    What has happened is that black students have redistributed themselves within both these state university systems. There are no longer as many blacks attending the respective flagship universities in these systems, but they are attending other institutions whose normal standards they meet, instead of being overmatched and flunking out of more prestigious institutions.

    A book by former university presidents William Bowen (Princeton) and Derek Bok (Harvard) had made a misleading case for affirmative action that the media have hailed as definitive. Bowen and Bok claim that the mismatching of black students under affirmative action has not produced the dire results predicted by critics. Their evidence? Black students graduate at higher rates at a particular set of elite institutions that Bowen and Bok have chosen to study than at lower ranked institutions in their study.

    The real issue, however, is not how highly ranked the institutions are, but how big the racial difference in admissions standards has been. This they never tell us, despite mountains of statistics on everything else. From other studies, however, it is clear that racial differences in SAT scores, for example, are much smaller at Harvard (95 points) than at Duke (184 points) or Rice (271 points).

    In other words, where the racial preferences in admissions are not as great, the differences in graduation rates are not as great. The critics of affirmative action were right: Racial preferences reduce the prospects of black students graduating. Other data tell the same story.

    Compare racial preferences in Colorado, for example. At the flagship University of Colorado at Boulder, test score differences between black and white students have been more than 200 points -- and only 39 percent of the black students graduated, compared to 72 percent of white students. Meanwhile, at the University of Colorado at Denver, where the SAT score difference was a negligible 30 points, there was also a negligible difference in graduation rates -- 50 percent for blacks and 48 percent for whites.

    In short, it is not the relative rankings of the institutions but the racial differential in admissions standards that has been crucial. You are not doing anybody a favor by sending them where they are more likely to fail, rather than where they are more likely to succeed. Critics of racial preferences and quotas have been saying that for more than 30 years, and now the data back them up -- which may be why you don't hear much about those data.
    Last edited by Reaper Man; 09-24-2009 at 10:45 PM.

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Pepper Corn View Post
    yes. useless.
    this is America bro.
    what happened to MLK again?
    and how many others?
    Yeah...that is why I want to start my own country.

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  14. #14
    Citizen Cope
    Zere's Avatar

    Country
    This is Zere's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Posts
    3,281

    Quote Originally Posted by Reaper Man View Post
    Will this be a real debate with a structure and time limits or the more typical college debate consisting of standing up in front of class and trying to talk over the other?
    Somewhere in the middle probably. It's supposed to be structured with one side making evidence/points for 7 minutes, then the other side attacks the evidence for 5 minutes, then the original side defends their points for 3 minutes. Then the scenario is repeated with the other side giving evidence. Then we have a Q&A where the yelling and the anger come out.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Chess Champion.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Fantasy Football Champion.

    FREE MONEY!!!

    you sign up, get 10 free cents to bet on all kinds of sports, get to 20 dollars you can cash out real money. If you lose the 10 cents they give you 10 more cents for free.

    http://www.centsports.com/?opcode=182035

  15. #15
    Citizen Cope
    Zere's Avatar

    Country
    This is Zere's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Posts
    3,281

    Many public schools in minority populated areas are poorly funded, leading to a worse education because of larger class sizes and a lack of technology and school programs. Many of these schools do not have English as a second language programs, so minorities who are still learning English cannot compete in the classroom. Therefore affirmitive action is right for college entrance, since these students did not have the opportunity to receive as good of an education growing up, they deserve an opportunity in college, and have the potential to be as smart or smarter than non-minority students who didn't have the poor public schooling conditions (giving them better qualifications for college even though they might not really be "smarter").
    Ninjashoes 2008 Chess Champion.
    Ninjashoes 2008 Fantasy Football Champion.

    FREE MONEY!!!

    you sign up, get 10 free cents to bet on all kinds of sports, get to 20 dollars you can cash out real money. If you lose the 10 cents they give you 10 more cents for free.

    http://www.centsports.com/?opcode=182035

  16. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by Zere View Post
    Many public schools in minority populated areas are poorly funded, leading to a worse education because of larger class sizes and a lack of technology and school programs. Many of these schools do not have English as a second language programs, so minorities who are still learning English cannot compete in the classroom. Therefore affirmitive action is right for college entrance, since these students did not have the opportunity to receive as good of an education growing up, they deserve an opportunity in college, and have the potential to be as smart or smarter than non-minority students who didn't have the poor public schooling conditions (giving them better qualifications for college even though they might not really be "smarter").
    Goddammit, I posted an essay with what is wrong with this and lost it all. This will be a summary.

    - Putting unqualified minorties in college who couldn't hack it in high school is just idiocy and will hurt both qualified and unqualified students. The qualified students will have their learning environment undermined (either by lower standards or time/money spent on remedial classes or both). The unqualified students will find themselves over their head in the degree of rigor expected of them and perform worse until they acquire the skills that their peers learned in middle school.

    These minorities need to learn the skills that would allow them to achieve a high GPA and ACT/SAT score so they can perform in college. The point of college is a higher education. Why make it a remedial high school?

    Let the minority children learn the langauge and academic skills they need at their own pace and then apply to college at that point (if they are still interested). Schools are always sympathetic to these cases provided their is evidence to back it up (a good writing sample and standardized test scores.

    Moreover, it is patently false that minority immigrants cannot perform as well as their white counterparts without political assistance. Japanese immigrants have demonstrated greater academic success and higher earning potential than whites after only a few generations.

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  17. #17
    Army of Wand
    Neo_Pop's Avatar

    Country
    This is Neo_Pop's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Reality
    Posts
    12,617
    Blog Entries
    4

    Quote Originally Posted by Zere View Post
    Discuss.
    No it hasn't.

    There's still a lot latent prejudice out there. A minority will always be assumed to be less educated, less articulate, less intelligent and more problematic than a non-minority. And factoring in that a minority is more likely to have less connections in the job market that will help them find a job find a job, the odds of them finding employment are less.

    Plus, people hire who they like, they mostly don't care if a person is more qualified than another, unless the job is really important.

  18. #18
    Uninspirational
    Radar's Avatar

    Country
    This is Radar's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Posts
    21,319

    How selective is Affrimative Action...? Are they mixing gang-bangers with the more intelligent inner-city kids and bussing them to school..?

    If a white kid has a chance to move to a better school based on their smarts, then anyone does

  19. #19
    Yeah--what are you defining as affrimative action? Are there quotas to fill and shit or are we just selecting a kid that marks "black" on their resume over a guy who moarks "white"?

    One night a man had a dream. He dreamed he was walking along the beach with the Lord. Across the sky flashed scenes from his life. For each scene, he noticed two sets of footprints in the sand: one belonging to him, the other to the Lord.

    Looking back at the footprints in the sand, he noticed that many times along the path of his life there was only one set of footprints. He also noticed that it happened at the very lowest and saddest times in his life. This really bothered him and he questioned the Lord about it.

    The Lord replied, "My son, My precious child, I love you and would never leave you. During your times of trial and suffering, when you see only one set of footprints, it was then that I carried you."

  20. #20
    Boxing Troll
    ItBurnzWhenIP's Avatar

    Country
    This is ItBurnzWhenIP's Country Flag

    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Conspiring to help K-1 rule the world
    Posts
    19,384


    ask the man on the far right what he thinks of that bullshit
    (ward connerly)
    #1 DIEGO "CHICO" CORRALES NUTHUGGER FOR ETERNITY!!

    "GIMME ONE ROUND!"
    -Chico

    Refusing to subscribe to the crap posting revolution

    According to a BMA study around 82% of men who took part in the vicious fights were gay before they started and another 12% became gay during their first fight.

    The remaining 6% took part in cage fighting because they wanted to beat up gay men.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •