View Full Version : cult of the soldier


thorbriand
10-14-2007, 07:28 PM
http://www.thenation.com/blogs/notion?pid=166592

The Cult of the Soldier
Christopher Hayes

Note to members of the United States House of Representatives on both sides of aisle: Soliders are people. Some volunteered out of patriotism, some out of economic desperation, some because they couldn't think of what else to do. Some of them are truly heroic, courageous, conscientious and brave. Some are racist and sadistic. Some are both at different times. Some began as kind-hearted and generous and have had their entire personalities change by the cruelties of war. Can we please, please, please stop pretending that we currently have 160,000 saints with guns patrolling the streets in Iraq? Can we please stop justifying the war in terms of it somehow being waged on the solider's behalf? Can we please acknowledge that our fetishization of our warriors is due to the fact that an ever-shrinking percentage of the population has been asked to sacrifice a single thing to wage this so-called epic struggle for freedom? Please?

InternetHero
10-20-2007, 12:33 PM
http://www.thenation.com/blogs/notion?pid=166592

The Cult of the Soldier
Christopher Hayes

Note to members of the United States House of Representatives on both sides of aisle: Soliders are people. Some volunteered out of patriotism, some out of economic desperation, some because they couldn't think of what else to do. Some of them are truly heroic, courageous, conscientious and brave. Some are racist and sadistic. Some are both at different times. Some began as kind-hearted and generous and have had their entire personalities change by the cruelties of war. Can we please, please, please stop pretending that we currently have 160,000 saints with guns patrolling the streets in Iraq? Can we please stop justifying the war in terms of it somehow being waged on the solider's behalf? Can we please acknowledge that our fetishization of our warriors is due to the fact that an ever-shrinking percentage of the population has been asked to sacrifice a single thing to wage this so-called epic struggle for freedom? Please?

What a stupid article. When you have 160,000 combat troops committing 1/5th the murders and rapes (While under combat stress.) that occur in many U.S. cities of the same relative size. It should be understood that most of the men there are more brave and noble than that pen pushing prick could ever dream to be.

Soldiers are people, and usually better people than sniveling journalists who's idea of sacrifice is having their coffee without sugar. What a sad joke. .